Crate and Barrel vs. Pottery Barn



Crate and Barrel and Pottery Barn are two popular retailers of home décor products. These are two companies that offer various ideal items. Even with some of the qualities that they have to offer, they are also different places in a number of ways.

Which Retailer do You Like Better?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Background

Crate and Barrel

Crate and Barrel was formed in 1962 in Chicago as a company dedicated to selling home products for young couples. The firm has around 170 stores around the world with half of them being in the United States. The German mail order company Otto GmbH owns Crate and Barrel.

Pottery Barn

Pottery Barn was founded in 1949 as a company dedicated to selling upscale décor products. Since 1986, it has been owned by Williams-Sonoma, a prominent kitchenware and home furnishings company. There are more than 600 locations around the world.

Advantage:

Although both have strong backings, Pottery Barn has more locations and therefore holds the advantage.

Furniture

Crate and Barrel

Modern furniture is a key focus in terms of what Crate and Barrel has to offer. The site has modern designs with simple wood surfaces around many of its products and softer fabric materials all around with leather and cloth alike being prominent.

Pottery Barn

There is a clear blend of modern and classic influences on the furniture pieces that Pottery Barn sells. Wooden materials are clearly emphasized more around the site. Lighter fabrics are also highlighted on the site with a greater emphasis on cloth materials.

Advantage:

Pottery Barn has a better variety of products for sale and therefore has the advantage here.



Décor

Crate and Barrel

Crate and Barrel sells a vast variety of décor products including lanterns, candle holders, vases and front door décor items. Classic metal designs are included as well as some carved wood materials. Throw pillows are available in a variety of textures and sizes as well.

Pottery Barn

True to the store’s name, Pottery Barn places a big emphasis on ceramic materials for its décor items. It sells many vases, throw pillows and wall décor items with an emphasis on wood and metal materials.

Advantage:

Crate and Barrel holds the edge here for having a greater assortment of décor items.

Linens

Crate and Barrel

Crate and Barrel has great rugs of all sorts including bath rugs and mats, area rugs and outdoor floor coverings. The company sells items in a variety of surfaces and patterns. These include high and low-pile items alike. The curtains for sale include options that come in many sizes and include both opaque and sheer models.

Pottery Barn

The rugs sold by Pottery Barn include solid and patterned options. Natural fiber and Persian-style rugs are included. Bath mats and larger outdoor models can also be found on the site. This goes alongside the shades and curtains that can be ordered and customized in any way a person sees fit.

Advantage:

Although the two companies offer a good assortment of designs, Pottery Barn has a better variety of choices.

Kitchen Products

Crate and Barrel

In addition to cookware and coffee products, Crate and Barrel also sells cutlery and various cooking utensils and gadgets. It also sells a series of small appliances. These include blenders, juicers and mixers to name a few.

Pottery Barn

Dinnerware, serveware and flatware are all sold by Pottery Barn. A full glassware section is available with a strong emphasis on items that can be used in a home bar area.

Advantage:

Crate and Barrel has a better number of products for sale here.

Organization

Crate and Barrel

Crate and Barrel sells many storage products including modular storage items that can be stacked and arranged next to one another. Modern wood storage bins and woven fabric containers are available.

Pottery Barn

There is more of an emphasis on woven fabric materials for the storage items sold by Pottery Barn. These items come in more sizes and are arranged with many specific needs in mind. These include options for bathroom and living room use alike.

Advantage:

The fact that people can customize their storage solutions with more design choices from Crate and Barrel makes that company the winner here.

Sale Offers

Crate and Barrel

The sales offered by Crate and Barrel typically go up to 30 percent off of original prices. The clearance section of the store offers some items available for up to 50 percent off of their original prices too. Free shipping deals are also available for many kitchen, table linen and vacuum and utility products.

Pottery Barn

Many of the discounts on select products at Pottery Barn are available for up to 25 percent off of their original prices. The clearance section has deals worth up to 60 percent off. Free shipping deals are good for a variety of linen and bedding products.

Advantage:

The sales offers are practically similar to each other. However, Crate and Barrel holds the key for how it offers more free shipping deals.

Credit Cards

Crate and Barrel

The Crate and Barrel credit card offers $20 in free rewards for every $200 one spends on orders in stores and online. Six-month financing is available on orders with the card. This offers no annual fees and provides customers with various special discounts throughout the year.

Pottery Barn

The Pottery Barn credit card provides $25 in rewards for every $250 spent. Twelve-month financing is available as well as exclusive rewards throughout the year. There are no annual fees on the card. Double reward events take place throughout the year as well.

Advantage:

Crate and Barrel gives people rewards sooner but Pottery Barn has a longer financing plan. This category is a total push.

Final Verdict

Crate and Barrel has a better variety of products for sale and a more refined and modern look that makes it stand out. Even though it doesn’t have as many locations as Pottery Barn, the versatility of the store makes it the better choice. Of course, every customer has the right to look at both to see which is right for them based on the sales available for the products they need. Let us know which of these two stores you feel is the best option by leaving a comment below. Thanks for reading this Crate and Barrel vs. Pottery Barn competition write up.